What an Italian experience at La Bohème! Sure was regretting years of Spanish whilst sitting in Lincoln Center squinting at the stage and the subtitles. The opera, set in 19th-century Paris, beautifully captures the struggles and passions of young, starving, broke artists. The absolutely magnificent live donkey and horse on stage were delightful surprises, adding a unique charm to the performance that I will never forget.
Rent, a musical inspired by the same stories La Bohème is based on, attempts to modernize this classic story, placing it in the gritty landscape of contemporary New York City. While it portrays the trials of artists grappling with love and loss, I didn’t feel a complete connection between the musical and the opera. If I hadn’t known the source material, I wouldn’t have assumed they came from the same origins. Especially given the emphasis on tuberculosis in the opera vs the focus on HIV. Plus the fact that Mimi Márquez nearly dies, but survives, compared to the opera in which Mimi actually does die.
Moreover, I wish Francine had a more prominent role in the opera rather than being merged with Mimi. Her character adds depth to the narrative, and it’s a shame to see it overshadowed. In the end, both works remind me of the short stories written long before these works, but they do have some key changes that give the artist their freedom to announce their “complete involvement in creating” a new loosely inspired work of art.

























