Before last weekend I had never seen an opera, nor had I ever had any intention of seeing one. La Boheme is the first opera I have ever seen, and likely the only I will see because I have no interest in Opera. The opera itself wasn’t horrible. I was neither bored nor captivated; caught in between indifference and mild curiosity throughout the entire performance. The captions provided in front of us were the only thing that made the performance tolerable because I could at least have some clue as to what was going on beyond the general context of the performers’ movements and the performance pamphlet handed to us when we took our seats.
The cast was obviously very talented, learning how to pronounce and sing Italian. They also obviously put on a good performance and were very convincing of their actions when not singing, even the extras, especially when they were outside while Musetta was introduced (I watched the extras while they froze to see if anyone moved, only 1 guy did and it was seconds after they first froze).
Even with subtitles and the play pamphlet, I was not able to 100% follow the plot due to the subtitles sometimes not displaying what was being said. I still was able to understand the general story of love, and I accidentally read the description of act 4 and spoiled Mimi’s death.
In keeping with the tradition of the struggling Bohemian, I did NOT pay for the copy of Rent that I watched, and after watching, I can say that the movie is a decent modern take on a timeless struggle. The movie roughly follows the same plot of La Boheme; a group of aspiring artists who are dirt poor do whatever they can to make it another day.
Rent, being only 30 years old, touches on many things that were relevant then and still are today. The Aids pandemic, homosexuality, drug abuse, gender identity, love, and poverty.
The movie did take some creative liberties, such as putting Collins(Colline) and Angel(Schaunard) into a romantic relationship, and having Angel be the one who dies instead of Mimi.
Rent is a far more accurate and modern representation of struggling to survive, beyond being an artist. It showed how having people made life more enjoyable and was easier to connect to because it’s only about 30 years old, instead of nearly 200, like La Boheme.
I think I would’ve enjoyed Rent more than La Boheme, no matter the quality of Rent, because Rent is much more relatable and is in English. Rent was actually enjoyable, though, with good music, and characters whose struggles, personally and communally, still persist even into today.